Changing Car Insurance from New Jersey to Indiana
Answer
No. Your current limits already exceed what Indiana requires. New Jersey requires 35/70/25 and Indiana requires 25/50/25. You cannot keep a New Jersey policy after you become an Indiana resident; the policy has to be rewritten for Indiana, which is also when the price changes.
Verified against the state agency source on .
Your New Jersey policy does not follow you to Indiana. Insurers rate, and regulators regulate, state by state.
Your deadlines in Indiana
- Driver's license
- 60 days
- Vehicle registration
- 60 days
- Insurance
- Before you register
When the clock starts: You are an Indiana resident once you establish a permanent home in the state.
New Jersey vs Indiana minimum coverage
| Coverage | New Jersey | Indiana | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bodily injury, per person | $35,000 | $25,000 | Lower |
| Bodily injury, per accident | $70,000 | $50,000 | Lower |
| Property damage | $25,000 | $25,000 | Same |
Leaving New Jersey
- Do you have to return your New Jersey plates?
- Recommended, not requiredReturning the plates is the cleanest way to close out a New Jersey registration. Plates can be returned at any MVC agency (staff or the outside drop box) or by mail with a self-addressed stamped envelope; keep the surrender receipt. The MVC asks for plate surrender only once your insurer reports the New Jersey policy dropped and a suspension notice follows, and even then its uninsured-motorist FAQ accepts other answers in place of the plate receipt: proof the vehicle is registered in another state, or a Plate Status Form (RSC-6). Source
- Must the New Jersey plates or registration be closed before you cancel the New Jersey policy?
- Not published by New Jersey Motor Vehicle CommissionThe MVC does not say the plates must be surrendered before the policy is canceled. They do say New Jersey law requires the registered owner to keep liability insurance, and that when an insurer reports a dropped policy on a vehicle still registered in New Jersey the MVC sends a suspension notice. The uninsured-motorist FAQ treats the answers to that notice as equal: send the plate-surrender receipt, send proof the vehicle is registered in another state, or send a Plate Status Form (RSC-6). Source
- Does New Jersey refund unused registration?
- NoThe MVC refund policy covers only double payments, certain benefit-program overpayments and listed exemptions (such as military members). There is no refund of unused passenger registration when you move away. Source
New Jersey vs Indiana: what changes
Injury claims system
New Jersey: No-fault, Indiana: At-fault (tort)
New Jersey is a no-fault state and Indiana is not: in Indiana, injury costs are claimed from the at-fault driver's insurer.
Personal injury protection (PIP)
New Jersey: Required, $15,000, Indiana: Optional
New Jersey requires PIP of at least $15,000; Indiana does not require it.
Vehicle inspection
New Jersey: None, Indiana: VIN check
Indiana requires a VIN check; New Jersey has no vehicle inspection, so this is a step you have not done before.
What you have to do
Move your car insurance to an Indiana policy
Before you register: within 60 daysIndiana's minimums are lower than New Jersey's. Your existing limits already satisfy the law, so keep them unless you have a reason to reduce cover.
Have the VIN verified
Tied to registration: within 60 daysYou must physically bring the vehicle to a BMV branch for a VIN inspection.
Exchange your New Jersey license for an Indiana one
Within 60 days60 days after moving to Indiana, if you hold a valid license from another state. The knowledge and road tests are waived on a valid, unexpired out-of-state license; expect a vision screening at the counter.
Title and register your vehicle in Indiana
Within 60 days60 days after becoming a resident, for both the title and the registration.
Surrender your New Jersey license
At the same appointmentIndiana keeps your New Jersey license when it issues the new one. You cannot legally hold two state driver's licenses at the same time, so bring the old card with you.
Build my New Jersey to Indiana checklist
Common questions
- Do I need to change my car insurance moving from New Jersey to Indiana?
- Yes, regardless of the limits. A policy is written to one state's law and rated to one state's address, so it must be rewritten for Indiana. On the limits themselves: New Jersey requires 35/70/25 and Indiana requires 25/50/25, so your current limits already satisfy the law.
- What are the minimum insurance requirements in Indiana?
- Indiana requires at least 25/50/25, which is $25,000 bodily injury per person, $50,000 per accident, and $25,000 property damage.
- Is Indiana a no-fault state?
- No. Indiana is an at-fault (tort) state: the driver responsible for the crash, through their insurer, pays. New Jersey is a no-fault state, so your claims will work differently here.
- How soon do I have to switch after moving to Indiana?
- In practice, before you register the car, and Indiana allows 60 days for that. The insurance is the step that unblocks the rest, so do it first.
- Will my premium go up moving from New Jersey to Indiana?
- That depends on your new ZIP code, your vehicle and your record, so the state pair alone cannot answer it. This page covers the legal floor: New Jersey requires 35/70/25 and Indiana requires 25/50/25. Get quotes for your new address instead of relying on a state-level average.
- What happens to personal injury protection moving from New Jersey to Indiana?
- New Jersey requires PIP of at least $15,000; Indiana does not require it.
Sources
Every figure on this page comes from the official source below, read on.
- Indiana Department of Insurance: motor vehicle insurance requirements (accessed 2026-08-07)
- Indiana Bureau of Motor Vehicles: vehicle registration (accessed 2026-08-07)
- New Jersey Department of Banking and Insurance: motor vehicle insurance requirements (accessed 2026-08-07)
- New Jersey Department of Banking and Insurance: liability minimums, no-fault and PIP (accessed 2026-11-16)
- New Jersey Motor Vehicle Commission: vehicle registration (accessed 2026-08-07)
- New Jersey Motor Vehicle Commission: new-resident deadline (accessed 2026-11-16)
- New Jersey Motor Vehicle Commission: vehicle inspection (accessed 2026-11-16)
- New Jersey Motor Vehicle Commission: new-resident tax (accessed 2026-11-16)
- NJ MVC: How to Restore Your Registration, uninsured motorist suspensions (plate surrender) (accessed 2026-11-16)
- NJ MVC: Plates (surrender) (accessed 2026-11-16)
- NJ MVC: Uninsured Motorist Enforcement FAQs (accessed 2026-11-16)
- NJ MVC: Refund & Payment Policy (accessed 2026-11-16)