Skip to content
New State Driver home

Changing Car Insurance from New York to South Dakota

Answer

Yes. You must raise your limits. New York requires 25/50/10 and South Dakota requires 25/50/25. You cannot keep a New York policy after you become a South Dakota resident; the policy has to be rewritten for South Dakota, which is also when the price changes.

Verified against the state agency source on .

Every state sets its own floor for liability cover, and New York and South Dakota do not set the same one.

Your deadlines in South Dakota

Driver's license
90 days
Vehicle registration
90 days
Insurance
Before you register

When the clock starts: Residency begins on establishing a permanent home in South Dakota.

New York vs South Dakota minimum coverage

Minimum liability limits compared between New York and South Dakota
CoverageNew YorkSouth DakotaChange
Bodily injury, per person$25,000$25,000Same
Bodily injury, per accident$50,000$50,000Same
Property damage$10,000$25,000Higher

Compare every coverage line in the interactive tool

Leaving New York

Do you have to return your New York plates?
Yes, requiredIf you register the vehicle in another state, you must surrender the New York plates and registration to the DMV, at an office or by mail. The DMV mails a plate-surrender receipt (FS-6T). Source
Must the New York plates or registration be closed before you cancel the New York policy?
Yes, close them firstSurrender the plates and registration before your New York coverage is canceled. If you switch to out-of-state insurance first, the DMV treats it as a lapse and may suspend your registration and driver license. Source
Does New York refund unused registration?
Partly, on a fixed scheduleFor a 2-year passenger registration: surrender within 60 days of issue with an unused sticker for the full fee minus $1; in the first year for 50% of the fee (1 year) minus $1; in the second year there is no refund. Plate, title and other fees and taxes are never refunded. Source
Anything else New York asks of a leaver?
Also notedMail copies of your out-of-state registration and insurance (if available) to the DMV Financial Security Bureau, P.O. Box 2725 ESP, Albany, NY 12220-0725. Each must show the registrant's name and address and the vehicle's year, make and VIN. Source

New York vs South Dakota: what changes

What you have to do

  1. Move your car insurance to a South Dakota policy

    Before you register: within 90 days

    South Dakota requires higher limits than New York, so your current policy will not satisfy the law on arrival. Ask your insurer to re-rate the policy to South Dakota limits from your move-in date. South Dakota also requires cover New York does not: Underinsured motorist. Do not cancel the New York policy yet: New York State Department of Motor Vehicles wants the New York plates returned first.

    Official page for this step

  2. Exchange your New York license for a South Dakota one

    Within 90 days

    90 days of establishing residency (30 days for a commercial license). The knowledge and road tests are waived on a valid, unexpired out-of-state license; expect a vision screening at the counter.

    Official page for this step

  3. Title and register your vehicle in South Dakota

    Within 90 days

    90 days from the date of arrival, to title and license the vehicle at the county treasurer's office. You should receive credit for sales or use tax already paid to your previous state.

    Official page for this step

  4. Surrender your New York license

    At the same appointment

    South Dakota keeps your New York license when it issues the new one. You cannot legally hold two state driver's licenses at the same time, so bring the old card with you.

    Official page for this step

Build my New York to South Dakota checklist

Common questions

Do I need to change my car insurance moving from New York to South Dakota?
Yes, regardless of the limits. A policy is written to one state's law and rated to one state's address, so it must be rewritten for South Dakota. On the limits themselves: New York requires 25/50/10 and South Dakota requires 25/50/25, so you must increase your cover.
What are the minimum insurance requirements in South Dakota?
South Dakota requires at least 25/50/25, which is $25,000 bodily injury per person, $50,000 per accident, and $25,000 property damage.
Is South Dakota a no-fault state?
No. South Dakota is an at-fault (tort) state: the driver responsible for the crash, through their insurer, pays. New York is a no-fault state, so your claims will work differently here.
How soon do I have to switch after moving to South Dakota?
In practice, before you register the car, and South Dakota allows 90 days for that. The insurance is the step that unblocks the rest, so do it first.
Will my premium go up moving from New York to South Dakota?
That depends on your new ZIP code, your vehicle and your record, so the state pair alone cannot answer it. This page covers the legal floor: New York requires 25/50/10 and South Dakota requires 25/50/25. Get quotes for your new address instead of relying on a state-level average.
When can I cancel my New York car insurance?
Only once the New York plates are returned. That comes after you register in South Dakota, which needs proof of a South Dakota policy. Surrender the plates and registration before your New York coverage is canceled. If you switch to out-of-state insurance first, the DMV treats it as a lapse and may suspend your registration and driver license.
What happens to personal injury protection moving from New York to South Dakota?
New York requires PIP of at least $50,000; South Dakota does not require it.

Sources

Every figure on this page comes from the official source below, read on.